Historical Accuracy Of Saving Private Ryan Essays


In the Allied invasion of Normandy, two brothers are killed in battle. Earlier on, a third brother was killed. Their mother is supposed to receive notice of their deaths all on the same day. Captain John Miller and his squad are sent on a rescue mission to find Private James Ryan, the fourth brother, and bring him home. However, finding him is harder than it seems because nobody knows exactly where he is. On their journey to find him, some of the squad is killed. Eventually, they locate Ryan, but when they ask him to leave with them, he refuses. He says that he cannot leave his unit, who is assigned to hold a key bridge. He claims that he has not earned any right to leave that the rest of his unit hasn't, and he'll stick by them. Hesitantly, Miller and his squad agree to help Ryan's unit defend their position, and they successfully hold of a German counter-attack.Unfortunately, during this counter-attack, Miller as well as a lot of his squad are killed. Ryan, does, however, survive, and makes it home to his mother. The movie ends with a scene where Ryan is visiting a veteran graveyard to see Captain Miller's grave, and his life after making it home is flashed before the audience's eyes.

Historical Analysis

Saving Private Ryan, directed by Steven Spielberg, is known to be one of the best World War II films ever created. The movie opens up in a battle at Normandy. This twenty-four minute battle scene is a perfect depiction of the actual D-Day/ The film really captures the brutality of the battle, and it may even be considered the best battle scene of all time. To make it even more believable, the aircraft are modeled just after the real ones used in World War II. Additionally, during the war, the government would offer relief to families who had already lost men in battle by sending who they have left alive, in this movie's case Private Ryan, back home to their families. This movie also did a pretty accurate portrayal of the horrors of war and the brutal conditions entwined in it. Soldiers were constantly losing fellow men withing their squads, and it was common for the fatally wounded soldiers to scream out in agony or even try to re-stuff their organs back into their bodies, like shown in this film. 
Despite all the aspects of war that Saving Private Ryan had gotten right, there were several errors.For example, throughout the squad's journey to find Private Ryan, they traveled mostly in the daylight. This never would have happened or even be allowed because of the dangers that would bring. Also, the soldiers were often shown wearing their helmets unbuckled which is irrational because soldiers knew that doing so is too hazardous. Additionally, in the film during the mission, the unit spoke a lot, too much. In reality, there never was all that much conversation. Similarly, the men seemed to have argued with their captain a lot, but that much back-talk would result in punishment if they really did do so.
The movie did focus primarily on the American war effort, but it is an American war film, so that must be expected. This historical inaccuracies can be forgiven because it is, after all, a fictional movie and is made for entertainment purposes. Like all movies, many details were dramatized to make it more interesting so it would make more money. Overall, Saving Private Ryan is ultimately a very accurate portrayal of World War II.

Relations between History and the Saving Private Ryan movie

Saving Private Ryan

The film “Saving Private Ryan” has, on the whole, fairly well respected the history of the landing.

The first part, that of the landing at Omaha Beach, is quite respectful towards History, except for what will be mentioned below:

The sea, after the landing, was not red with blood, but black because of the German shells which sank into the mud and made it rise to the surface.

– The place found to turn the scene (in Ireland) does not resemble the beaches of the landing of Normandy.

– The landing in the film seems very short compared to what the American soldiers endured on June 6, 1944 in the morning. Some units remained more than 5 hours on the beach without being able to advance an inch.

– The beach defenses called “Rommel Asparagus”, whose purpose was to damage the hulls of the landing craft, are placed upside down in the film.

– Contrary to an idea too widespread and shared again in this film, not all American amphibious tanks have flowed in the English Channel. Indeed, some units were very severely hit, but no fewer than 58 tanks reached the beach in the early hours of the assault at Omaha Beach. To learn more about amphibious armored vehicles, click here.

The second part of the film, which represents the vast majority of the Battle of Normandy, delivers the plot of the film and is inspired by the environment of these 90 days of fighting for Americans in the Normandy bocage. The fact is that at the beginning of the war four brothers, the Niland brothers, who were united within the same unit, were killed when the boat they served was sunk during a Japanese attack In the Pacific. This loss to the Niland family provoked a strong reaction on the part of American public opinion and all the brothers who served in the same unit were separated to avoid such a misadventure. The film “Saving Private Ryan” is inspired by this real fact but adapts it. To learn more about the Niland brothers, click here.

This film is the most realistic of the feature films on the landing of Omaha Beach. The camera games, which have been used on the shoulder, give a presence effect to the very innovative action that all modern warfare films take up (for example, Michael Bay’s “Pearl Harbor” movie, 2001) .

Sound is a fundamental part of the film. To the point of perfection, the sounds of bullets entering the flesh were taken by specialists who fired live bullets on lifeless carcasses of cattle.

The equipment carried by the actors of “Saving Private Ryan” are authentic. Director Steven Spielberg wanted his actors to feel the weight of weapons, fighting bags and vintage shoes so that their movements would be the most faithful to those of the soldiers of the Second World War. This detail has its importance in that the unity represented by Tom Hanks and his men is the Ranger Battalion, an elite unit of the US Army.

To represent the story in the smallest details: this notion appears to be essential to the filmmakers of war films since the end of the 1990s. It was an era too close to the war where the films had to remember the victory without the pain and the sacrifices, And who were ultimately not respectful of history in large part. Nowadays, directors seem to be seeking perfection, in the most realistic possible way, while being careful not to forget these pains and sacrifices. Our need to commemorate the past and to remember the facts of war like these go through a high level of detail, like films like “Saving Private Ryan” or “Band of Brothers”, often violent but realistic.

Back to the Saving Private Ryan menu

0 thoughts on “Historical Accuracy Of Saving Private Ryan Essays”


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *